Climate Corner: Jimmy Carter – visionary

Feb 1, 2025

Vic Elam

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

Recently deceased former President Jimmy Carter grew up close to the land, hunting, fishing, and farming his family’s property near Plains, Ga. From those experiences Carter developed an ethic of environmental stewardship that remained with him throughout his life and influenced his political leanings.

Early in his political career as the governor of Georgia, Carter stood in the way to save a river from being dammed after paddling the river and seeing the natural beauty that would be destroyed. As president, Carter struggled to protect the environment from development and instead pivoted to provide protections for more than 150 million acres of federal lands.

Climate science was not as well established in the late 1970s, when Carter was in office, but even then, it was showing undeniable evidence that carbon dioxide gas build-up in the atmosphere was contributing to a green house effect. Carter was the first global leader that understood the science and its implications and took measures to decrease carbon emissions. Although some of Carter’s actions had unintended consequences that may have increased carbon emissions, he led with intention that was unmistakable. Many of Carter’s mandates were well ahead of their time and set the stage for much of the advances in energy efficiency that we enjoy today.

Oil shortages at the time also forced Carter to look at renewable energy sources to help us reduce our dependency on oil. This phenomenon is not unlike the energy situation that we are finding ourselves in today. The state of Virginia is one such example; by providing sales tax incentives, data centers needed to support the burgeoning artificial intelligence and cryptocurrency markets are increasing and expected to dramatically increase further electricity demands. The projected 183% increase in power demand by 2040 would require an additional large natural gas plant every year and a half, along with wind energy that is expected to come online and combined with increased solar and potentially nuclear plant additions to meet the needs.

Virginia consumers may have to bear the burden of all this power development by paying much higher utility rates and suffering environmental degradation. The Mid-Ohio Valley may not be immune to similar impacts as the quest for more and faster data ramps up.

Without the energy crisis that his administration had to endure and with the environmental impact information available now, there’s no telling what President Carter may have accomplished. He stepped forward into the dark trusting the available science, yet as science has improved and shed more and more light on the climate change problem, most leaders since Carter have largely put sunglasses on and ignored the light. Now it seems that the light is as bright as a welding arc, and still our elected lawmakers are donning a welding helmet and pretending the issue will just go away or refusing to acknowledge it. We need everyone to see the light that science has cast upon our condition and act accordingly, our future depends on it.

Carter did more than any president in history following his presidency to create peace and prosperity, but following his presidency he was looked upon as one of the worst for a few reasons. In retrospect, President Carter was a role model who was well ahead of his time, and he is now regarded among the greatest.

Rest in peace President Carter.

***

Vic Elam is an avid outdoorsman and contributor to organizations that share his concern for our environment, including Mid-Ohio Valley Climate Action.

 

Climate Corner: Having it both ways – a cleaner environment and economic growth

Jan 25, 2025

George Banziger

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

It’s a frequently held assumption, often promoted by fossil-fuel interests, that in order to pursue a cleaner environment, we need to make sacrifices for economic development. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Recent events, internationally, nationally and locally, have put into stark relief the urgency required to address climate change and to reduce the risks and costs associated with the extraction of fossil fuels. Data from around the world have revealed that 2024 was the hottest year in recorded history (National Centers for Environmental Information). The devastating wildfires in southern California are the product of an extended drought in that area and extreme Santa Ana winds. Jordan Thomas, a retired California firefighter, quoted in a recent edition of the New York Times (Jan. 16, 2025), said: “To (prevent) catastrophic fires like these we must stop burning fossil fuels…” The Ohio legislature allowed — even encouraged — hydraulic fracturing, i.e., fracking, under public lands, including state parks in a bill (HB 507) that took effect in 2023. With more fracking comes more brine waste, that is, produced waste, much of it coming to Washington County, which leads the state in the volume of this waste material injected into its grounds. As my Climate Corner colleague, Dr. Randi Pokladnik, pointed out in her piece a week ago, much of this waste is radioactive (containing Radium 226 and 228) and contains PFAS (forever chemicals), carcinogenic substances, and other toxic chemicals.

In its economy so dependent on fossil fuels, especially natural gas, the Mid-Ohio Valley is more of a dumping ground for waste products than an economic growth engine. But where are the profits, jobs, and prosperity from these extractive industries going and how much benefit to the Appalachian region accrues from these investments? In a study done by the Ohio River Valley Institute (July 2021), it was reported that from 2008-2019 in the 22 counties in Ohio, in western Pennsylvania, and in West Virginia, which produce 90% of the natural gas in Appalachia, economic prosperity, in terms of jobs, income, and population growth, trailed the U.S. measures of these factors. The demographics of our region continue to show a decline of population as young people choose to leave. Natural gas extraction and plastics manufacturing are capital-intensive enterprises. What is needed for job creation and sustained prosperity in the region is activity that is labor-intensive and that produces wealth which remains in the region.

There are many opportunities for economic development in Appalachia, even in manufacturing, which can serve as alternatives to extractive industries. Biomaterials, such as hemp, which can be readily grown in the region, algae, and mycelium (mushroom roots) can serve as a phased-in alternative to plastics (Patton and Rudek, 2024). Production of batteries for vehicles which reduce greenhouse gas emissions is another promising idea. Locating and capping abandoned oil and gas wells can provide many jobs in the region (32,000 such jobs according to ORVI). There are now more jobs in the solar and wind industries in Ohio than in the coal industry (U.S. Energy and Jobs Report, U.S. Department of Energy, 2023). Research on the use of coal tailings to produce rare-earth metals, which are used in electric vehicles and other modern applications, is producing promising results. Parts for wind turbines can be manufactured in Appalachia.

ReImagine Appalachia, a group committed to transforming the economy of this region from one based on extractive industries to one based on sustainable practices, has promoted the concept of circular manufacturing. The latter strategy assumes that materials never become waste and that nature is regenerated when products and parts are used over again according to a principle of reduce, reuse, repurpose.

Appalachian communities where economic investments are being made should be assured that their communities will receive long-term benefits from any major investments in their areas including the following: that local labor will be hired on construction and manufacturing jobs (to be paid at prevailing wages), that environmental standards will be applied (e.g., clean air and clean water), and that green space and affordable housing will be provided. These assurances have been formalized into community benefit agreements, now a requirement for grant-funded projects supported by the U.S. Department of Energy.

Job-training programs are being developed in Appalachia for those who have been involved with the criminal justice system, through drug-related crimes and those in drug-treatment programs. These efforts seek to address one of the critical endemic social problems of Appalachia.

***

George Banziger, Ph.D., was a faculty member at Marietta College and an academic dean at three other colleges. He is a member of the Green Sanctuary Committee of the First Unitarian Universalist Society of Marietta, Citizens Climate Lobby, and of the Mid-Ohio Valley Climate Action team.

Suggested Readings for January

MOVCA Selected Media Postings November & December 2024 (plus a few missed in the last listing)

Compiled by Cindy Taylor

NOTE from Cindy: When scrolling through this selected media listing, you will find some media postings openly available without any costs, while other sites may have a paywall or request contributions (or registration). MOVCA appreciates the coverage provided by independent journalists, coalition groups and all media sources that publicize climate and environmental concerns, sustainable solutions, legislative actions, and opportunities for community members to learn and make a difference. Public libraries and educational institutions have many of these sources available to everyone.

 

 

Available online in The Parkersburg News and Sentinel:

 

December 14, 2023  Staff report

“West Virginia Rivers Coalition lawsuit accuses Chemours of polluting waterway”

https://www.newsandsentinel.com/news/business/2024/12/west-virginia-rivers-coalition-lawsuit-accuses-chemours-of-polluting-ohio-river/

 

 

Available on WTAP:

December 5, 2024 Feature by Chase Campbell

“Japanese business delegation visits Polymer Alliance Zone, SOMAR”

https://www.wtap.com/2024/12/05/japanese-business-delegation-visits-polymer-alliance-zone-somar/

 

November 25, 2024 Feature by Logan Riggenbach Text and Video

“Pickering Energy Solutions receive grants for solar panel projects”

https://www.wtap.com/2024/11/26/pickering-energy-solutions-receive-grants-solar-panel-projects/

 

November 18, 2024  Feature by Chase Campbell  Text and Video

“Ohio Natural Energy Institute receives ARC funding for orphan well workforce development initiative”

https://www.wtap.com/2024/11/18/ohio-natural-energy-institute-receives-arc-funding-orphan-well-workforce-development-initiative/

 

Available on MOVCA Youth Climate Ambassadors Program:

November  2024    News post: “We’ve Been Busy! Youth Climate Ambassadors and Air Quality Monitors”

https://www.movyouthca.com/news

 

Available on the Charleston Gazette-Mail:

November 21, 2024    Op-ed by Eric Engle

“Eric Engle: Time for climate action is short”

https://www.wvgazettemail.com/opinion/op_ed_commentaries/eric-engle-time-for-climate-action-is-short-opinion/article_2068d78a-a83f-11ef-82ba-975216ddd3fe.html

 

See articles by Mike Tony, Environment and Energy Reporter:

https://www.wvgazettemail.com/news/energy_and_environment/

 

Here are a few examples:

December 17, 2024  Article by Mike Tony, Environment and Energy Reporter

“EPA proposes granting WV authority over wells critical to carbon capture projects”

https://www.wvgazettemail.com/news/energy_and_environment/epa-proposes-granting-wv-authority-over-wells-critical-to-carbon-capture-projects/article_807f3b5c-ac16-11ef-88b8-af3fcd2be7e4.html

 

December 12, 2024  Article by Mike Tony, Environment and Energy Reporter

“ ‘We should know what we’re breathing’: Community air monitoring expanding in WV”

https://www.wvgazettemail.com/news/energy_and_environment/we-should-know-what-were-breathing-community-air-monitoring-expanding-in-wv/article_052dc19c-ad80-11ef-ae61-039fae8586f7.html

 

November 14, 2024     Article by Mike Tony

“ ‘Don’t let ARCH2 in the door!’: Hydrogen hub opposition persists after open house”

https://www.wvgazettemail.com/news/energy_and_environment/dont-let-arch2-in-the-door-hydrogen-hub-opposition-persists-after-open-house/article_40e02c18-a1d5-11ef-ae70-17c0843a7304.html

 

Available on Cleveland.com:

December 6, 2024    Guest Column by Randi Pokladnik

“Appalachian hydrogen hug is a dirty-energy boondoggle that should be canceled: Randi Pokladnik”

https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2024/12/appalachian-hydrogen-hub-is-a-dirty-energy-boondoggle-that-should-be-canceled-randi-pokladnik.html

https://main.movclimateaction.org/2024/12/07/appalachian-hydrogen-hub-is-a-dirty-energy-boondoggle-that-should-be-canceled/

 

Available on Herald-Star:

December 14, 2024 Local Column (poem) by Randi Pokladnik

“Guest column/Our very own ‘Nightmare Before Christmas’

https://www.heraldstaronline.com/opinion/local-columns/2024/12/guest-column-our-very-own-nightmare-before-christmas/

 

Available on Mountain State Spotlight:

January 3, 2025 Environment Article by Sarah Elbeshbishi

“Residents near the proposed Appalachian hydrogen hub can voice their concerns about the project”

https://mountainstatespotlight.org/2025/01/03/doe-arch2-public-comment/

 

December 19, 2024 Environment Article by Sarah Elbeshbishi

“A new limit on toxic air emissions proposed by Biden’s EPA faces Trump’s anti-regulation agenda”

https://mountainstatespotlight.org/2024/12/19/epa-polyether-polyols-limit/

 

November 25, 2024 Environment Article by Sarah Elbeshbishi

“Developers drop out of Appalachian hydrogen hub over strict carbon emission caps”

https://mountainstatespotlight.org/2024/11/25/arch2-hydrogen-hub-developers-drop-out/

 

Available on Save Ohio Parks: https://saveohioparks.org

December 20, 2024  Statement by Cathy Cowen Becker, co-leader of Save Ohio Parks

“Save Ohio Parks Statement on Passage of HB 308: A Lump of Coal to Ohio Elected”

https://saveohioparks.org/2024/12/20/save-ohio-parks-statement-on-passage-of-hb-308-a-lump-of-coal-to-ohio-electeds/

 

December 19, 2024 Press Release by Melinda Zemper

“Save Ohio Parks Demands Gov. Mike DeWine Veto Law Expanding Fracking Leases and Declaring Nuclear Energy ‘Green’”

https://saveohioparks.org/2024/12/19/save-ohio-parks-demands-gov-mike-dewine-veto-law-expanding-frack-leases-and-declaring-nuclear-energy-green/

 

November 3, 2024  Save Ohio Parks Blog Press release

“Guernsey County Commission Votes to Deny Spreading of Toxic Oil and Gas Waste”

https://saveohioparks.org/2024/11/03/guernsey-county-commission-votes-to-deny-spreading-of-toxic-oil-and-gas-waste/

 

Available on West Virginia Rivers Coalition:

December 2024 WV Rivers News: Updates from WV Rivers Coalition

https://wvrivers.org/2024/12/wv-rivers-news-december-2024/

 

December 11, 2024 News Release – contact Maggie Stange

“New Report Highlights Impacts of Mountain Valley Pipeline on Streams and Wetlands in West Virginia”

https://wvrivers.org/2024/12/mvp-impact-report/

 

December 5, 2024 News Release – contact Maggie Stange

“WV Rivers Coalition Inc, Taking Chemours to Court”

https://wvrivers.org/2024/12/wv-rivers-coalition-taking-chemours-to-court/

 

November 2024  News article  “Conductivity and ionic pollution: what it is and why it matters”

https://wvrivers.org/2024/11/conductivity-and-ionic-pollution/

 

posted October 30, 2024 Action Alert: “November 2024 Public Meetings on Energy & Water Protections”

https://wvrivers.org/2024/10/november-public-meetings/

 

Available on West Virginians for Energy Freedom:

December 30, 2024 Article

“Pepper Reviewing Appalachian Power Rate Increase Request”

https://www.energyfreedomwv.org/news/2024/12/30/pepper-reviewing-appalachian-power-rate-increase-request

 

Available on Ohio River Valley Institute (ORVI):

January 6, 2025 Article by Joe Cullen

“BIL/IRA Implementation Digest – January 6, 2025”

https://ohiorivervalleyinstitute.org/bil-ira-implementation-digest-january-6-2025/

 

January 2, 2025 Article by Sean O’Leary

“Load Growth Fever, LNG, and the Risk of Higher Electric Rates”

https://ohiorivervalleyinstitute.org/load-growth-fever-lng-and-the-risk-of-higher-electric-rates/

 

December 20, 2024 “2024 in Review” by ORVI staff

https://ohiorivervalleyinstitute.org/2024-in-review/

 

December 9, 2024 Article by Joe Cullen

“BIL/IRA Implementation Digest – December 9, 2024”

https://ohiorivervalleyinstitute.org/bil-ira-implementation-digest-december-9-2024/

 

November 11, 2024 Article by Joe Cullen

“BIL/IRA Implementation Digest – November 11, 2024”

https://ohiorivervalleyinstitute.org/bil-ira-implementation-digest-november-11-2024/

 

November 8, 2024 Research Article by Ted Boettner

“Filling the Hole: A Federal Solution to Cleaning Up America’s Orphaned and Abandoned Oil and Gas Wells”

https://ohiorivervalleyinstitute.org/filling-the-hole-a-federal-solution-to-cleaning-up-americas-orphaned-and-abandoned-oil-and-gas-wells/

 

Available on ReImagine Appalachia:

See all events (to register) and access recordings and resources: https://reimagineappalachia.org/events/

January 14 & 15, 2025 11AM -2PM Both Days    “ReImagine Appalachia Virtual Strategy Summit”

https://reimagineappalachia.org/reimagine-appalachias-2025-strategy-summit/

 

Thursday, December 12, 2024 12-1PM Webinar “Appalachian Flood Policy Platform”   Recording available

Public Webinar by Appalachian Citizens’ Law Center, ReImagine Appalachia & National Wildlife Federation

https://reimagineappalachia.org/appalachian-flood-policy-platform-webinar/

 

December 23, 2024 Blog Post by Liam Gerrity, Digital Media and Communications Specialist, Reimagine Appalachia

“2024: A Year in Review at ReImagine Appalachia”

https://reimagineappalachia.org/2024-a-year-in-review-at-reimagine-appalachia/

 

December 16, 2024 Blog Post by Kate Rudek, Research Associate ReImagine Appalachia

“Going Bio: Building a Bioplastics Industry in Appalachia”

https://reimagineappalachia.org/going-bio-building-a-bioplastics-industry-in-appalachia/

 

December 9, 2024 Blog Post “Direct Pay- How Local Governments & Nonprofits Can Get a Tax Return for Their Clean Energy Project (even Though They Don’t Pay Taxes)”
https://reimagineappalachia.org/direct-pay-how-to-get-a-tax-return-for-clean-energy-projects/

 

Available on West Virginia Citizen Action Group:

Posted November 27, 2024  Invitation “Join Us to Celebrate 50 Years of Citizen Action – January 11”

Because of weather, event will be rescheduled; See https://wvcag.org/50th-postponed/

 

Available on Conservation West Virginia:

See WV Conservation’s list of details and evaluation on current bills before legislature regarding: Clean Air, Pure Water, Climate, Land & Wildlife and Development:  https://www.conservewv.org/issues/

 

Appalachian Voices https://appvoices.org 

December 26, 2024 Article by Chelsea Barnes 

“How the Department of Government Efficiency’s plans will harm Appalachian communities: Part 2”

https://appvoices.org/2024/12/26/part-2-impoundment-law-and-doge/

 

December 18, 2024 Article by Chelsea Barnes 

“How the Department of Government Efficiency’s plans will harm Appalachian communities: Part 1”

https://appvoices.org/2024/12/18/department-of-government-efficiency-part-1/

 

Available on FaCT (Faith Communities Together for a Sustainable Future:  https://factsustain.org

See  Distinguished Speakers: https://factsustain.org/Distinguished/

December 2024 Distinguished Speakers Event “Big Oil’s Dirty Secret: Toxic Radioactive Brine Waste”

Meet FaCT’s 3 Brine Education Interns from Marietta College, Kent State U. and Kenyon College.

From main website https://factsustain.org/  a Zoom Recording link is provided.

 

Available on Halt the Harm Network:

November 21, 2024 by Elissa Yoder

“Celebrating 10 Years of the Community Sentinel Awards” & “Meet the 2024 Community Sentinel Awardees”

https://halttheharm.net/celebrating-10-years-of-the-community-sentinel-awards/

 

Available on E&ENEWS by Politico:

November 25, 2024 ENERGYWIRE Article by Carlos Anchondo

“EPA plan would give West Virginia authority over CO2 wells”

https://www.eenews.net/articles/epa-plan-would-give-west-virginia-authority-over-co2-wells/

 

Available on Environmental Health News EHN:

December 13, 2024 Article by Katherine McMahon and Sarah Howard

“Takeout food, bottled water linked to higher microplastic exposure”

https://www.ehn.org/microplastics-takeout-food-exposure-2670450952.html

 

November 22, 2024 Article by Katherine McMahon and Sarah Howard

“ ‘We have enough evidence’ to act on toxic plastic exposure now”

https://www.ehn.org/chemicals-in-plastic-healthcare-2669974107.html

 

November 12, 2024 Article Kristina Marusic and Cami Ferrell

“Hydrogen hubs test new federal environmental justice rules’

https://www.ehn.org/hydrogen-hubs-test-new-federal-environmental-justice-rules-2669585004.html

 

SEE ALSO THESE EVENTS, RESOURCES, RESEARCH AND ARTICLES OF INTEREST

Available on US Department of Energy: Office of NEPA and Compliance –

“DOE/EIS-0569: Appalachian Hydrogen Hub”

https://www.energy.gov/nepa/doeeis-0569-appalachian-hydrogen-hub

 

See Resources available on Fractracker Alliance:  see https://www.fractracker.org/about-us/

 

Available on U.S. Department of Agriculture:

December 5, 2024 Feature by Leah Roffman, Climate Fellow, Office of Chief Economist

“USDA Launches Interactive Agriculture and Forestry Greenhouse Gas Data Viewer”

https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2024/12/05/usda-launches-interactive-agriculture-and-forestry-greenhouse-gas-data-viewer

 

Available on United Nations:

November 24, 2024  News Announcement

“COP29 UN Climate Conference Agrees to Triple Finance to Developing Countries, Protecting Lives and Livelihoods”

https://unfccc.int/news/cop29-un-climate-conference-agrees-to-triple-finance-to-developing-countries-protecting-lives-and

See also “UN Climate Change Conference Baku – COP29” (November 11- 24, 2024)

https://unfccc.int

See also – Available on United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs- Sustainable Development:

“The 17 GOALS”  video and Text

https://sdgs.un.org/goals

 

Available on Inside Climate News:

November 13, 2024 Article by Nicholas Kusnetz

“Oil Industry Asks Trump to Repeal Major Climate Policies”

https://insideclimatenews.org/news/13112024/oil-industry-asks-trump-to-repeal-major-climate-policies/

 

Available on The Guardian:

January 7, 2024 Article by Tom Perkins

“Environmental groups sue FDA over refusal to tackle risky plastic packaging”

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/jan/07/fda-phthalates-plastic-lawsuit

 

December 11, 2024 Article by Tom Perkins

“EPA bans widely used chemicals linked too cancer before Trump takes office” Move to ban TCE and perc, commonly used in everyday products, will make it harder for Trump to undo rules.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/dec/11/epa-bans-chemicals-linked-to-cancer

 

December 11, 2024 Article by Tom Perkins

“Cotton-and-quid-bone sponge can soak up 99.9% of microplastics, scientists say”

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/dec/10/microplastics-pollution-sponge-cotton-squid-bone

 

November 29, 2024 Seascape: the state of our oceans. Article by Emma Bryce in Busan

“We need to talk about plastic: five everyday items choking the planet”

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/nov/29/we-need-to-talk-about-plastic-five-everyday-items-choking-the-planet

 

November 14, 2024 Article by Oliver Milman

“Trump promise to repeal Biden climate policies could cost US billions, report finds”

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/nov/14/trump-clean-energy-climate-policies

 

See also the report available on Net Zero Industrial Policy Lab:

November 6, 2024 Report by Bentley Allan and Tim Sahay

“Trump’s proposed clean energy retreat: US costs and global rewards”  Analysis shows disincentivizing US solar and battery manufacture could cost billions and open new supply chain markets for competitors.

https://www.netzeropolicylab.com/trump-retreat

 

November 12, 2024 Article by Dharna Noor

“”Big oil firms knew of dire effects of fossil fuels as early as 1950s, memos show”

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/nov/12/big-oil-fossil-fuel-warning

 

Available on Environmental Working Group:

December 17, 2024 Article by Monica Amarelo

“EPA must limit discharges of ‘forever chemicals’ to protect public health”

https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news/2024/12/epa-must-limit-discharges-forever-chemicals-protect-public-health

 

November 26, 2024 Article by JR Culpepper (EWG)

“Top 5 ways to reduce your microplastic exposure”

https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news/2024/11/top-5-ways-reduce-your-microplastic-exposure

 

November 26, 2024 Article by Ketura Persellin (EWG)

“Toxic chemicals in the kitchen: 5 low-stress clean swaps”

https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news/2024/11/toxic-chemicals-kitchen-5-low-stress-clean-swaps

 

November 19, 2024 Article by Ketura Persellin (EWG)

“Greenwashing: Truth versus hype about consumer products”

https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news/2024/11/greenwashing-truth-versus-hype-about-consumer-products

 

Available on Common Dreams:

December 27, 2024 Article by Brett Wilkins

“EPA Promoting Fertilizer Full of PFAS Despite Knowing Risks”

https://www.commondreams.org/news/sewage-sludge-fertilizer

 

December 18, 2024 Article by Jessica Corbett

“ ‘Monumental Win’: Montana Supreme Court Upholds Decision on Youth Climate Case”

https://www.commondreams.org/news/montana-supreme-court-climate-change

 

December 10, 2024 Article by Julia Conley

“ ‘Landmark Victory’: US Proposes Endangered Species Protections for Monarch Butterfly:

https://www.commondreams.org/news/monarch-butterfly-endangered

 

Available on Yale Climate Connections:

December 9, 2024 Article by Michael Svoboda

“12 books to gift for the holidays in 2024”

https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2024/12/12-books-to-gift-for-the-holidays-in-2024/

 

December 6, 2024 Article by Samantha Harrington

“How to give climate-friendly gifts this holiday season”

https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2024/12/how-to-give-climate-friendly-gifts-this-holiday-season/

 

November 6, 2024 Article by Daisy Simmons

“How to protect your pet from climate change”

https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2024/11/how-to-protect-your-pet-from-climate-change/

 

Available on Earthday.org; https://www.earthday.org

Posted  “Earth Day 2025 : OUR POWER, OUR PLANET”

https://www.earthday.org/earth-day-2025/

Includes links to planning events and many resources such as Quizzes, Fact Sheets, Articles and MORE.

 

December 23, 2024 Climate Action Article

“6 Myth busting Arguments for Your Anti-Facts Family this Holiday Season”

https://www.earthday.org/6-myth-busting-arguments-for-your-anti-facts-family-this-holiday-season/

 

December 14, 2024 Article by Kristina Lantz

“The Dark Side of Sports: Sportswashing and Climate Change”

https://www.earthday.org/the-dark-side-of-sports-sportswashing-and-climate-change/

 

 

 

Climate Corner: The Ohio Valley has a radiation problem

Jan 18, 2025

Randi Pokladnik

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

During the 60s, I remember the government conducted Civil Defense drills in my school. We were told to climb under our school desks, duck down, and cover our heads. We might have survived a bomb blast but the radioactive fallout could not be stopped. The nuclear disasters at Three-Mile Island, Chernobyl, and Fukushima have taught us that the radiation emitted during an accident or bombing will travel across the planet via prevailing winds and the jet stream and distribute some radiation to all of us.

Decades later, while pursuing my masters degree, I had the opportunity to visit Los Alamos, N.M. This city was built to house scientists secretly working on nuclear weapons and was the setting of the 2023 movie about J. Robert Oppenheimer, “father of the atomic bomb.” He was an American theoretical physicist who worked on the Manhattan Project and was the director of the Los Alamos Laboratory where the atomic bomb was developed.

I saw streets lined with barbed wire fencing, cameras mounted on every telephone or power pole, and guard stations at every corner. During our time there, we learned about the many experiments conducted by the federal government on unknowing citizens. When they detonated the Trinity bomb “officials chose not to evacuate the area, nor to warn residents of potential health effects.”

Native Americans who worked in Uranium mines died from radiation exposures. “From 1944 to 1986, nearly 30 million tons of uranium ore were extracted from Navajo lands.” Officials knew the mines (which were often located near or on reservations) exposed entire communities to radiation, but they failed to alert the workers and the families living in the region.

On Jan. 6, 2025, “The Environmental Protection Agency and Navajo Nation finalized a plan to transport one million cubic yards of waste from the Quivira Mines site to a disposal cell near Thoreau, N.M. The Quivira Mines are one of the largest and most high-risk uranium mine sites on the Navajo Nation” and according to EPA spokesman Michael Brogan, have high concentrations of Radium-226 and Uranium. The Safe Drinking Water Act sets the maximum contaminant level (MCL) for Radium-226 in drinking water at 5 pico Curies per liter (pCi/L).

Unfortunately, a similar scenario has been occurring in Southeastern Ohio. Since 2012, when fracking for oil and gas started in earnest in the tri-state area, communities, citizens, and oil and gas workers continue to be exposed to brine and fracking sludge that can contain alarming amounts of radioactive isotopes like Radium-226 and Radium-228. Every day, brine trucks that are lacking any warning placards or Material Safety Data Sheets, drive along our roads and through our towns transporting oilfield wastes from fracking well pads to Class II injection wells. In addition to bromine and chlorine salts, these trucks can also carry toxic chemicals, pit waste, refuse water, sludge, and even used frack sand along with water soluble Radium-226.

Justin Nobel’s book, “Petroleum 238” is an excellent source of information detailing how the oil and gas industry has been allowed to spew radiation across the United States in the form of billions of gallons of oilfield wastes. Oil and gas exploration and production wastes (brine and drilling muds) were exempted from the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) Subtitle C in 1978. They are also exempted from Ohio’s hazardous waste regulations. This isn’t because the wastes are safe, in fact, officials admit the wastes could indeed be harmful to human health and the environment.

The primary reason for the exemption was “if the immense volume of oil and gas wastes were regulated as hazardous it would economically harm the industry.” When the law was revisited in 1980 under President Reagan, the Environmental Protection Agency kept the exemption, saying regulations would “cause a severe economic impact on the industry and on oil and gas production in the U.S.” Basically, as far as politicians and regulatory agencies are concerned, industry profits supersede any concern for the health of our communities.

A big fear is that the radiation from Radium-226 (which has a half-life of 1600 years) and Radium-228 (half-life 5.75 years) will be poisoning the tri-state region long after the fracking boom is over. Radium isotopes have been shown to cause bone, liver, and breast cancer in humans. “The Ohio Administrative Code (OAC) has set environmental discharge limits for Radium 226 and 228 at 60 pCi/L each,” yet it is not unusual for brine trucks to carry fluids testing above 3,000 pCi/L, with some as high as 7,300 pCi/L, according to the Buckeye Environmental Network brine factsheet on conventional and horizontal well brines; both contain Radium isotopes.

In 1985, Ohio’s General Assembly approved the use of vertical well oilfield brine to be used on roadways as a deicer and dust suppressant. In 2004, Ohio passed HB 278, “which took away local control on oil and gas regulation and granted Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) sole authority,” meaning local communities cannot stop an injection well from being constructed. There is an injection well less than ten miles from my home. Ohio has over 234 Class II injection wells and accepts wastes from out-of-state. Each day, countless brine trucks loaded with toxic horizontal well wastes travel along Tappan Lake, a drinking water source for Cadiz, Ohio.

We cannot depend on the ODNR or Ohio Environmental Protection Agency to safeguard our communities from oil and gas wastes. Several grassroots groups have taken on the task of educating the public about this radioactive nightmare. One of these is the Ohio Brine Task Force. “The Brine Task Force is a group of thoughtful and committed Ohioans interested in stopping the hazardous practice of brine spreading in our communities.”

The Buckeye Environmental Network is hosting a Statehouse Symposium at the State Capital- “Spreading Oilfield Brine on Ohio’s Roadways” on March 6 from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. where attendees will hear from workers affected by oilfield brine contamination and scientific experts on why this is an urgent issue to address.

***

Randi Pokladnik, Ph.D., of Uhrichsville, is a retired research chemist who volunteers with Mid Ohio Valley Climate Action. She has a doctorate degree in environmental studies and is certified in hazardous materials regulations.

Climate Corner: Cost, convenience and conservation

Nov 2, 2024

Dean Banziger

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

I like to consider myself a conservationist, or in other words, concerned about our environment and limited resources. However, if I am honest with myself, it is not always a top priority. Cost and convenience are more often a deciding factor for me than impact on the environment. I just do not have unlimited funds or unlimited time to always make the “green” decision.

Often, though, cost and conservation due coincide. My recent car purchase is a good example.

Before making a final decision on buying a car, I debated first between gasoline and electric vehicles. Being a math teacher and former actuary, I crunched the numbers. Based on driving an average amount of 1,000 miles per month and getting 30 miles per gallon at $3.50 per gallon, a gas-powered vehicle would cost $1,680 to fuel each year. An average electric car gets 4 miles per kilowatt hour, and an average West Virginia household pays $.12 per kilowatt hour for electricity. So, based on traveling the same 1,000 miles per month, an average Wet Virginian would pay $360 to fuel a fully electric vehicle. I have kept my previous cars for about 10 years. So, looking only at fuel, I would save $1,392 per year, or $13,020 over the 10 years that I plan to own the vehicle.

Next, I looked at sticker prices. For new 2024 vehicles, the average cost of cars, after taxes and fees was around $30,000. Looking at EVs, the average new car cost was $40,000, after taxes and fees. The initial sticker price of EVs was significantly higher, but the federal government is now offering a $7,500 rebate for buying new EVs assembled in the United States (https://www.energy.gov/save/electric-vehicles). The rebate combined with the $13,000 in fuel savings make a new EV $3,000 less.

So, a new EV would be less expensive, over time, than new gas vehicles. While I could afford a payment on a $30,000 or even $40,000, this just seemed too much for me to spend. Also, if I financed the EV, the interest on the bigger loan would eat up a lot of my savings. To me, cars are a mode of transportation, not a fancy item to show off to friends. My wife and kids will be the first ones to tell you that I can be quite a miser.

So, I considered used cars. After talking a lot with others, I found a neighbor looking to sell their 2017 Chevy Bolt (fully electric) for the same cost that I was finding gas and hybrid cars of similar age. Well, what about battery life? After a little more research, I found that EVs lose just 2.3% of their battery life each year (https://www.evconnect.com/). This would give me the 10 years of life that I was looking for. As a bonus, Chevrolet recalled the batteries on the 2017 vehicle. So, the one I purchased had a brand new battery installed in 2022. Even if I had not had the good fortune of getting a new battery, the low battery loss each year still makes used EVs an affordable and practical option. The federal government also provides tax rebates on used cars like this one, as well (see energy.gov for details).

If the battery has no issues, the cost of maintenance on an EV will be less. Like my battery powered mower (that I love and have had for 5 years), I never have to change the oil, replace a spark plug, or flush coolant. There is not even a transmission to have issues.

OK, so “the man” will get me on car insurance rates, right? Surprisingly, when I shopped for my car insurance, I found the same coverage that my wife has on her Subaru Forester for less cost (Chevy Bolt cost: $375 per year, Forester cost: $500 per year). The stories that I have heard about EV batteries “blowing up” are mostly just rumors and not affecting insurance costs.

Along with cost, convenience is important to me. Will buying an electric car keep me from driving long trips? My children each live about 120 miles away, well within the 300-mile radius of most EVs. So, I can visit either of my kids in an EV without having to charge until I get back home. My wife and I go on one to two big trips a year. While newer EVs can “super-charge” in less than an hour, my wife and I plan to still use her gas-powered Subaru Forester for these long trips. Having one gas vehicle gives us a lot of flexibility. I am helping the environment with an EV, and not sacrificing convenience much, by having a gas vehicle in our household.

In the end, looking at cost, convenience, and conserving natural resources like fossil fuels, buying an EV was the right decision for me. I hope that this helps you in making balanced decisions that protect our limited resources and your pocketbook.

***

Dean Banziger, M.S. is a mathematics teacher at Williamstown High School.

 

Climate Corner: Driving a used EV by the numbers

Jan 11, 2025

Jonathan Brier

climatecorner@brierjon.com

In April 2024 I wrote “How my life changed driving a used EV.” It was just over 12 months ago I purchased a used Hyundai Kona Electric with 20,202 miles. A couple weeks before the 12 months mark of ownership, I doubled that number. Most of this is my commute of about 100 miles round trip and a few long trips amounting to 200 to 1,500 miles each. What have I learned from one year of EV ownership?

Cutting to the chase, I am saving money. Somewhere between $500 and $800 compared to my previous car AFTER factoring in the difference in increased insurance and the increased registration fee and estimating an average of $3 per gallon of regular (the U.S. average for that period was $3.49, so this is a conservative). My maintenance costs disappeared except for the $25 for tire rotation; the only liquid to change in my car is battery coolant.

My previous car, a 2006 Toyota Corolla, was reliably getting 32-38 mpg with most of my driving being highway. My EV is getting about 100 mpg (one gallon of gas is about 33.4 kwh). Answering the questions my neighbors and others have asked me:

* How often do I plug-in to charge?

Two days a week at least, the day before I commute 100 miles. It really depends on how much I drive and where I want to go.

* How much does charging cost?

My home electric rate is about $0.16 per kwh with both generation and AEP Ohio’s transmission and distribution charges. On average I drive 1,800 miles a month. In the summer, my car is more efficient and does 100 miles in about 22.2 kwh making recharging $3.56. In the winter, because I have an older EV without a heat pump for heating, I’m losing some additional range to heat my car and the battery is less efficient. In winter, 100 miles when it’s really cold, like below 32 degrees Fahrenheit, my refill would be about 31.25 kwh depending on how I drove. That is $5.

So between $3.56-$5 for my EV for 100 miles, while my Corolla cost between $8.57-$9.38 for the same 100 miles. For 1,800 miles, the Corolla cost $154.26-$168.84 vs. the EV cost of $63.54-$90. I did fast charge with DC, so these are the low end.

When compared to a 2010 Prius hybrid at 50 mpg average, the cost for charging vs. gas is nearly a wash when it was cold in December/January. Warmer months’ travel with an EV is cheaper even with higher rates than home for the fast charging. $0.30-$0.65 per kwh I’ve seen on a trip.

* How long does it take to charge?

When I visit family, I only have access to a 15-amp, 120-volt outlet like in any home. If I’m really low on battery, it may take 24-48 hours to get back to full since that would only add three to five miles per hour. A level 2 charger, aka 240 volts, recharges faster in three to four hours. A DC fast charger on trips will go from 20-80% in 30-50 minutes depending on outside temps. Newer EVs can do this in 15-20 minutes.

There is much outdated information and knowledge on EVs and I can’t get to everything here.

Battery life: Most EV owners won’t ever need to get a battery replacement. Battery management systems have greatly matured, and the chemistry of the batteries is rapidly improving in both safety, density and material needs. They even have life after a vehicle. A startup called Element Energy is using old EV batteries for grid storage. Redwood Materials is claiming 95% efficiency for material recovery when recycling them. The company Recurrent tracks and rates EV battery status for those who opt in or sell EVs, so you know its health.

So, if you’re wondering if you should buy an EV, do the math. It may work out that you can save the green in your wallet and the future of our planet.

***

Jonathan Brier is a Marietta resident, information scientist, data librarian and an Eagle Scout. He is a member of the Association of Computing Machinery, American Association for the Advancement of Science, OpenStreetMap US, Mid-Ohio Valley Climate Action and a Wikipedia contributor. If you would like to reach him, visit https://brierjon.com or email: climatecorner@brierjon.com

Climate Corner: Dollars and (common) sense

Jan 4, 2025

Griffin Bradley

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

With the 2024 elections behind us and a second Trump administration preparing to take control in a few short weeks, I find it to be a time of reflection on the last four years. The good, the bad, and the ugly. Despite the rhetoric around America’s political realities and what the future may hold, we must also look back at the consequential policy of the Biden administration and the indelible impact it had on clean energy and climate.

The 2022 Inflation Reduction Act set a new standard for prioritizing clean energy and climate issues, putting hundreds of billions of dollars toward cleaning up our energy system, stabilizing our aging grid, and more. Over the last four years, America has seen monumental investments in clean energy and climate priorities by the federal government and private businesses alike. Now, with a new administration and a Republican trifecta in Washington, the risk of backtracking on the commitments and progress we have seen across the country is real.

We’ve all heard for months that deficit hawks in Congress look to take a “scalpel, not a sledgehammer” to spending in the next federal budget. This concept begs an overarching question: what gets cut, and who does it impact? Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., has made it clear that he sees IRA funding as a key source of cuts, but little is known on what parts will stay and what parts will go. What we do know, however, is that there remains a strong contingent of Republican House members who support the IRA.

But, wait. Hasn’t one of the key talking points of the Republican Party throughout the last election cycle been that the federal government is wasting taxpayer dollars on “woke” climate issues? Then why have 18 Republicans — a bloc well large enough to tank any initiative of the current five-seat majority — signed a letter stumping for a Biden administration policy?

Well, it turns out that injecting capital into projects that have direct benefits for Americans is a popular endeavor, regardless of what party’s administration made it happen.

Since the passage of the IRA, the lion’s share of funding (nearly 4x) has gone to Republican districts. From EV battery manufacturing in North Carolina to budding energy storage technologies being developed right here in West Virginia, we are seeing an economic renaissance of sorts. Blue collar, hard-working areas of America that have been looking for new opportunities in a new economy have got it, due in no small part to the IRA.

A recent report shows over 3.3 million Americans are employed in the clean energy space as of 2023, a number that has steadily increased since 2020. Beyond federal recognition that clean energy and climate is worth investing in, these burgeoning jobs numbers show that corporate and private-sector entities agree and have doubled down on their commitments to a cleaner world. From the corporations that make many of your household products to the small startups that are on the bleeding edge of technology, there is continued support and ambition tied to investments in climate issues.

While we don’t yet know what is to come for these substantial programs and investments, we have so many examples of the good that federal funding has done, not just for clean energy and climate, but for restoring the economic value of rural America. We have the opportunity to simultaneously lift up broad swaths of our country while also making it a better place for our children, grandchildren and beyond to thrive. So, when the inevitable fight around funding in Washington starts and the IRA is on the chopping block, remember what is really at stake.

This is more than just dollars and cents.

***

Griffin Bradley is a lifelong Wood County resident, graduate of West Virginia University (B.A., Political Science ’21; M.A., Political Science ’23), and a contributing author for Mid-Ohio Valley Climate Action.

Climate Corner: A Challenge and an Opportunity

Dec 28, 2024

Rebecca Phillips

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

2024 has been a year of climate-related disasters. On Dec. 19, Reuters published one photo from each of the countries mentioned in its coverage this year: of the 125 countries, 22, or more than 15%, of the images featured the aftermath of floods, wildfires, hurricanes, droughts, or heat waves, and this in a year that saw political upheavals and wars across the globe. In the United States alone, wildfires burned 8.4 million acres, a million and a half more than the average of the last ten years, which have seen historically high fire numbers. The eighteen named storms of the Atlantic hurricane season devastated places as far from the coast as Asheville, N.C. and, combined, caused $190 billion in damages. Twenty-four of this year’s climate-related events caused more than $1 billion each in damage and resulted in 418 human deaths in just the U.S.

The areas most at risk for property damage and loss of life are those to which Americans have been moving in recent decades, specifically, the South and Southwest. Arizona’s large cities are possible only because of water diversion from the Colorado River, and that river is drying up. Some Phoenix-area developers have been unable to get building permits because there is not enough water available to service the homes they want to build. Many home insurers have stopped writing policies for hurricane-prone areas of Florida, leaving the state the only insurer available, with half a trillion dollars in liabilities. The National Flood Insurance Program was $21 billion dollars in debt, debt for which taxpayers are ultimately responsible, before the damage caused by hurricanes Helene and Milton.

As Scripps Prize-winning journalist Abrahm Lustgarten puts it in his book “On the Move: The Overheating Earth and the Uprooting of America,” “Drought, coastal flooding, crop failures, intensifying hurricanes, extreme heat, and wildfires will begin to overlap and close in on the country from its edges, slowly making entire regions less attractive and even, in some extreme cases, unlivable. … Decades from now, the United States will be wildly different, even unrecognizable.”

These changes may make some currently growing areas less desirable. While the last few decades have seen more people leaving areas like the MOV than moving here, researchers have noticed what may be the beginning of a new pattern of climate migration, people leaving fire-and hurricane-prone areas for safer parts of the country. Many of these migrants have chosen to settle in the so-called Rust Belt, our country’s former industrial heartland. There have recently been numerous conferences and a fair amount of press on the Great Lakes region as a “climate haven,” an area likely to avoid the worst effects of climate change. Universities and think tanks have been exploring how Rust Belt cities can prepare for population gain. Already, Duluth, Minn., markets itself as “climate-proof Duluth” and in the last few years has seen nearly 2,500 new residents from other states, many of them escaping wildfires and high temperatures. This number represents an over 3% increase in its population after decades of decline. Invest Appalachia has issued a report on the central Appalachians, an area that includes the Mid-Ohio Valley, as a region that can absorb climate migrants and revitalize our communities in the process.

Yes, despite the destruction that climate change is wreaking, we can use this challenge to strengthen the communities in our less-climatically-threatened region. Go to nearly any town or city in Ohio or West Virginia and count the empty homes, retail buildings, and former schools.

Many of these are sturdy buildings in established areas, well worth saving if there were people to do so. In addition to physical infrastructure, our region contains close-knit, welcoming communities. Imagine Wood and Washington counties with 7,000 or so additional residents bringing their skills and ideas, easing labor shortages, creating new businesses raising families. This is a possible dream if we prepare for it, as Marietta is doing with the Reimagine Marietta process.

Creating the physical and social infrastructure for a growing rather than a declining region is not an easy task, but a crisis can provide an opportunity. Climate change is almost certain to bring a stormier, hotter, more dangerous world with less land hospitable to human civilization; however, in our region we have the opportunity to grow and strengthen communities that can thrive more than they ever have.

My wish for the New Year.

***

Rebecca Phillips taught research writing at WVU Parkersburg and is a member of Mid-Ohio Valley Climate Action.

Climate Corner: The solstice and our fragile balance

Dec 21, 2024

Jean Ambrose

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

This morning at 4:21 a.m., as most of us in West Virginia were still in bed, the Earth paused. Today marks the winter solstice — the shortest day and longest night of the year in the Northern Hemisphere. At this precise moment, our planet, wobbling on its 23-degree axial tilt, stopped leaning away from the sun and began tilting back toward it. The term “solstice” originates from the Latin solstitium, meaning “sun standing still,” symbolizing this fleeting moment of stillness before the Earth shifts its course.

This axial tilt is vital for life, shaping our seasons and moderating Earth’s temperatures to sustain an extraordinary diversity of organisms, including humans. Ancient cultures, deeply attuned to the seasons, built structures like Stonehenge in England, Machu Picchu in Peru, and the Cahokia mounds in Illinois to track celestial events. These monuments testify to humanity’s deep reliance on nature’s cycles and the celebration of the solstice as a time of balance and renewal.

The winter solstice signifies both an ending and a beginning. While the cold and darkness prevail, Earth’s subtle tilt triggers the first signs of change. Plants and animals begin to respond to the lengthening days, setting the stage for spring’s rebirth. For centuries, cultures have commemorated this turning point with rituals and feasts, emphasizing themes of renewal, community, and the enduring promise of light. These traditions serve as reminders of our shared humanity and connection to the rhythms of nature.

Yet, in our modern lives, we have grown distant from these cycles. This detachment not only weakens our sense of belonging but also harms our stewardship of the planet. While ancient peoples found comfort in the predictability of seasonal patterns, today, human activities are disrupting these natural rhythms. The climate crisis–fueled by deforestation, fossil fuel consumption, and unchecked industrialization–is destabilizing the very cycles we once depended on. Seasons are shifting, temperatures are rising, and ecosystems are under mounting stress.

In its resilience, Earth is attempting to rebalance itself, but the strain caused by humanity’s thoughtless greed is unprecedented. Unchecked pollution, exploitation of natural resources, and rampant greenhouse gas emissions have pushed the planet’s climate systems into disarray. The natural cycles that once ensured stability can no longer be trusted in the same way. This unsettling reality underscores the consequences of prioritizing short-term gains over long-term sustainability. By pushing Earth beyond its limits, we endanger not just the environment but our own future.

The solstice invites us to reflect on the balance between darkness and light, not just in nature but in our relationship with the planet. Reconnecting with the natural world–whether by eating local foods according to the seasons, reducing our carbon footprint, or simply observing the beauty around us — offers a pathway to restore harmony. It reminds us of the intricate web of life we belong to and the responsibility we share to protect it.

As we celebrate the return of the sun, let us also pledge to safeguard the cycles that sustain life. The solstice is more than a moment in time; it is a call to action. Even in the darkest moments, there is potential for renewal and growth. By confronting the climate crisis, we honor the wisdom of the natural world and help secure a brighter, more sustainable future for all.

So when you hang a wreath, let it remind you of the wheel of life. Shut off the electricity and light candles as you feast with friends and family. Appreciate the sun and soil and water that were essential to the food on your table and the contributions of immigrants and marginalized communities who make this abundance possible. Finally, as we gather in our communities, be strengthened in the sure knowledge that we cannot protect our families, our futures, or our planet alone — we will always need each other.

***

Jean Ambrose lives on a ridge near Mountwood Park.

Climate Corner: No peace for Earth

Dec 14, 2024

Aaron Dunbar

editorial@newsandsentinel.com

In October of 1963, Bing Crosby released his iconic rendition of the classic holiday song, “Do You Hear What I Hear?” While the song’s lyrics are in clear reference to the Nativity, it was originally written and composed by the husband and wife duo of Noel Regney and Gloria Shayne, during the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis. Listened to from this perspective, it becomes clear that the mention of stars “with a tail as long as a kite” and pleas to “pray for peace, people everywhere” were a direct response to the very real nuclear fears of the age.

“I had thought I’d never write a Christmas song,” Regney once recounted. “Christmas had become so commercial. But this was the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis. In the studio, the producer was listening to the radio to see if we had been obliterated. En route to my home, I saw two mothers with their babies in strollers. The little angels were looking at each other and smiling. All of a sudden, my mood was extraordinary.”

At the time of its writing, Shayne confessed that the two of them were unable to even fully perform the song themselves due to the emotional intensity of its subject matter. “Our little song broke us up. You must realize there was a threat of war at the time.”

Six decades on, and this haunting holiday tune sadly maintains the same degree of relevance as the day that it was written. Last year on Christmas Day, the birthplace of Christ was literally being bombed with munitions manufactured and provided to Israel by the United States. This year, the same administration perpetrating the genocide in Gaza is doing everything it can to provoke nuclear conflict with Russia on its way out the door, funneling billions in weapons to Ukraine and twisting Volodymyr Zelenskky’s arm to try and lower his country’s draft age to 18. Our tragic failure to learn from history and to insist on imperialist conflict escalation over diplomacy makes a song like “Do You Hear What I Hear?” truly evergreen.

As someone who genuinely loves this time of year, I find myself increasingly shaken by the jarring contrast of the holiday season with the ongoing destruction of our planet, whether through war or environmental catastrophe — or, as is often the case, through the intermingling of both.

It may be that I’m out holiday shopping, my car’s radio tuned in to Christmas carols for the entire month of December, and apropos of nothing I’ll find myself contemplating a near certain future in which the Global North’s consumption of fossil fuels has locked the world into 2C or more of global warming. This in itself would be enough to kill off 99% of the world’s coral reefs, and likely lead to the deaths of more than a billion people — and yet it increasingly seems that this figure is on the low end of what we can expect in years to come.

Walking past a mall Santa, I can’t help but think of the North and South Poles heating faster than anywhere else on the planet, or the Antarctic Doomsday Glacier that’s been melting at an accelerated rate, threatening catastrophic sea level rise.

Santa himself, I’m reminded, was largely popularized in his modern-day form by Coca-Cola, a company which has been named the largest plastic polluter on the planet for some five years in a row at this point. Evidently not satisfied with limiting themselves to a single area of environmental desecration, in 2024 Coke decided to replace their widely celebrated and iconic holiday ads with a series of visually grotesque commercials created through generative AI. This technology, as I detailed in a previous Climate Corner column, is expected to contribute to a doubling of the world’s energy needs by 2026, accelerating the already disastrous rate of global heating while also guzzling down millions of gallons of water, leading to global scarcities of this most vital resource.

It’s strange to me, as well, to watch a nation that proudly labels itself as “Christian,” celebrating the birth of Christ while living as culturally divorced from His teachings as possible. Violence and overconsumption have become our national brand, and we’ve taken to worshiping the corrupt CEOs and arms dealers making billions from the engineering of mass scale human tragedy as their own kinds of messiahs. Jesus, in His teachings, is unmistakable in His condemnation of the rich to the fires of hell, as well as His uplifting of the poor, the meek, and the foreigner upon this earth. Why, then, in 2024, when the chasm between the wealthy and poor has never been greater, when the lies and corruption of the wealthy and those in power have never been of more tragic consequence to the world than they are now, are we taught by our culture to emulate those who have gone completely insane with greed, and to reject the poor, the vulnerable, and those in need from among our number?

Finally, as yet another year of climate inaction draws to a close, I find myself wondering how many “good years” we still have left before things truly start to collapse. Even this, I know, is a privileged notion to entertain, as I lie under warm blankets in a well-heated home, with plenty of food to eat, clean water to drink, and so far mostly insulated from the ravages of the climate crisis, which have already left so many with nothing in this world. I do my best to go about my business, making plans for a future I know the generation of children being born today will likely never have. I read about yet another “hottest year on record” in the books, knowing that this will only be true until next Christmas rolls around.

In spite of all of this, my love for the true spirit of the holidays remains undamped. Noel Regney’s “pray for peace, people everywhere” is a call to action that stays with me year round. Not just to pray for it, but to personally manifest it, and to try to give back whatever amount of light into this ever darkening world that I can.

***

Aaron Dunbar is a member of Mid-Ohio Valley Climate Action.